Spesia & Taylor

Attorneys at Law

(815) 726-4311
  • History
  • Attorneys
    • John M. Spesia
    • Christian G. Spesia
    • Jeffrey S. Taylor
    • Michael R. Stiff
    • Jacob E. Gancarczyk
    • Michael A. Santschi
    • Haley G. Peters
    • Alexander J. Boyd
    • Michelle M. Kavanaugh
    • John R. Rodack III
    • James C. Byrne
    • E. Kent Ayers
    • Thomas M. Ewert
    • Kent F. Slater
    • Dinah Lennon Archambeault
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Eminent Domain
    • Employment & Civil Rights
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Real Estate & Zoning
    • Energy & Utilities
    • School Law
    • Municipal Law
    • Appellate Practice
  • News & Cases
  • Testimonials
  • Philanthropy
  • Contact
  • Home
You are here: Home / Commercial Litigation / Appellate Court Affirms Dismissal Of Lawsuit In Favor Of Easement Holder

Appellate Court Affirms Dismissal Of Lawsuit In Favor Of Easement Holder

June 21, 2021

Pipeline Construction, An energy company, represented by Spesia & Taylor

The Second District Appellate Court affirmed dismissal of landowners’ claims for being barred by the statute of limitations. See Super Mix of Wis., Inc. v. Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America, LLC, 2020 IL App (2d) 190034. An energy company, represented by Spesia & Taylor, was sued by landowners after the company refused to move and reroute its pipeline located in an easement on the properties at issue. The energy company’s easement had existed since 1945 on the property. Nearly sixty (60) years later, the plaintiffs purchased the property subject to the energy company’s easement. The landowners, operators of a mining operation, allegedly requested the energy company remove and relocate the easement to the property boundary. Failing to reach an agreement, the landowners filed suit claiming that they were entitled to damages because of their inability to reclaim their mine due to the presence of the pipeline. The energy company moved to dismissed the complaint as being time barred pursuant to 735 ILCS 5/2-619(a)(5).

Plaintiffs argued that their cause of action arose in 2015 when the energy company purportedly denied their request to move the pipeline. The court held that “any potential cause of action under the easement agreement accrued in 1945 when plaintiffs’ predecessors in interest knew or reasonably should have known of the injury to the property and that the injury was caused wrongfully.” Super Mix at ¶41.

Plaintiffs also argued that the energy company was required to accommodate the mining operation. Affirming long-standing principles of easement interpretation, the appellate court found that the energy company was not obligated to move its pipeline. The appellate court reaffirmed that the energy company, as the user of the right of an easement, enjoys a dominant estate over the landowners’ property and rejected the landowners argument that an easement should be discarded “simply when doing so becomes profitable” to the owner of the property. See Super Mix at ¶¶ 43 and ¶50.

Filed Under: Commercial Litigation, Eminent Domain, Energy & Utilities, News & Cases Tagged With: Appellate Practice, Commercial Litigation, Eminent Domain, Energy & Utilities, Spesia & Taylor, Super Mix of Wis. Inc. v. Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America LLC 2020 IL App (2d) 190034

Schedule a Consultation:

Contact us today to set up a time to speak with a Spesia & Taylor professional about your legal needs. CLICK HERE!

Featured News:

Providing Bicycles To Improve Opportunities For High School Students In Rural Malawi

In rural Malawi it is common for students to walk as far as 10 kilometers, each way every day, to attend the nearest high school. According to ... Read More

Warm Heart Ministries Assists With The Opening Of The Harris High School In Likwakwanda, Malawi

When Fr. Philip Mbeta was enrolled at Illinois Benedictine University, studying for his PhD, he served as an associate pastor at St. Mary Immaculate ... Read More

Spesia & Taylor Successfully Defends the City of Crest Hill in High-Profile Civil Rights Case

By: Michael R. Stiff Spesia & Taylor attorneys Jeff Taylor, and Mike Stiff on July 28, 2021, won a Motion to Reconsider the 2019 denial of a ... Read More

Amendments to the Illinois residential real property transfer on death instrument act provides more estate plan tools to individuals in order to avoid probate

The Illinois Residential Real Property Transfer Act (755 ILCS 27/1, et seq.) (the “Act”) provides for an owner, or co-owners, to transfer Illinois ... Read More

Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” in 2021

This September, Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor were each recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” by LeadingLawyers.com. ... Read More

1415 Black Road
Joliet, IL 60435
Phone: (815) 726-4311
Fax: (815) 726-6828

Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Sitemap

footer-logo-1footer-logo-3footer-logo-4


© Copyright 2018 Spesia & Taylor Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved. Design by MoatzArt