Spesia & Taylor

Attorneys at Law

(815) 726-4311
  • History
  • Attorneys
    • James C. Byrne
    • John M. Spesia
    • Christian G. Spesia
    • Jeffrey S. Taylor
    • Michael R. Stiff
    • Jacob E. Gancarczyk
    • Michael A. Santschi
    • E. Kent Ayers
    • Thomas M. Ewert
    • Kent F. Slater
    • Haley G. Peters
    • Aly N. Harms
    • Alexander J. Boyd
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Eminent Domain
    • Employment & Civil Rights
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Real Estate & Zoning
    • Energy & Utilities
    • School Law
    • Municipal Law
    • Appellate Practice
  • News & Cases
  • Testimonials
  • Philanthropy
  • Contact
  • Home
You are here: Home / Eminent Domain / Landowner Testimony in Condemnation Cases

Landowner Testimony in Condemnation Cases

April 7, 2017

Published in the Illinois Government Lawyers Association Journal
Something to Think About

By Jacob E. Gancarczyk and Christian Spesia

The goal in any condemnation proceeding is to determine “just” compensation – i.e. compensation that places the landowner in the same economic position as they were in prior to the taking. In order to determine the amount of compensation that is owed to the landowner both parties typically hire appraisers. In addition to the appraisers, the landowners whose property is subject to eminent domain are generally considered qualified to testify about the value of their property as a whole. This is because the law recognizes that generally owners are knowledgeable about how much their property is worth because they purchased it, as well as the amounts the routinely pay in taxes and that they receive as rents and incomes derived from it. However, this general rule does not give a landowner an absolute right to the admittance of their testimony in condemnation cases. In Illinois Extension Pipeline Company, L.L.C. v. Kuerth, 2016 IL App (4th) 150519, the Fourth District Appellate Court approved the trial court’s barring the landowners’ from testifying at trial. The court acknowledged that land valuation in condemnation proceedings is complex, and suggested that, despite the general rule, a landowner still has to show that their opinions have a sufficient basis and are credible.

The landowners in Kuerth sought more than five hundred-thousand dollars in compensation for a mere 3.6 acres of permanent-pipeline easement based on “fear” and “stigmatism” which they alleged were associated with oil pipelines. The landowners argued they were able to testify to such elements by the very fact that they were the landowners. In addition, the landowners argued that even if such elements were found to be improper, the opinions should still not be barred in their entirety because their use of improper elements of damage should only go to the weight of the evidence, not its admissibility. The Fourth District Appellate Court in Kuerth rejected these theories and approved the barring of the landowners who based their opinions, in part, on “subjective, speculative, and improper” elements. The court concluded that any witness who bases their opinions, in part, on improper elements effectively makes their entire testimony inadmissible. Ultimately, the appellate court approved a directed verdict in favor of the energy company, represented by Spesia & Taylor, for just compensation totaling 1% of the total amount sought by the landowners.

Filed Under: Eminent Domain, News & Cases

Schedule a Consultation:

Contact us today to set up a time to speak with a Spesia & Taylor professional about your legal needs. CLICK HERE!

Featured News:

Spesia & Taylor Successfully Defends the City of Crest Hill in High-Profile Civil Rights Case

By: Michael R. Stiff Spesia & Taylor attorneys Jeff Taylor, and Mike Stiff on July 28, 2021, won a Motion to Reconsider the 2019 denial of a ... Read More

Amendments to the Illinois residential real property transfer on death instrument act provides more estate plan tools to individuals in order to avoid probate

The Illinois Residential Real Property Transfer Act (755 ILCS 27/1, et seq.) (the “Act”) provides for an owner, or co-owners, to transfer Illinois ... Read More

Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” in 2021

This September, Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor were each recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” by LeadingLawyers.com. ... Read More

New Job Opportunity For Associate Attorney At The Law Firm Of Spesia & Taylor

Well established, dynamic, AV rated law firm is seeking associate attorney to join our practice. The law firm of Spesia & Taylor has been proudly ... Read More

Will County Legal Opportunity Scholarship Program Award Recipient Announced

Spesia & Taylor is a proud sponsor of the Will County Legal Opportunity Scholarship Program. The Scholarship awards a $5,000 per year up to three ... Read More

1415 Black Road
Joliet, IL 60435
Phone: (815) 726-4311
Fax: (815) 846-2410

Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Sitemap

footer-logo-1footer-logo-3footer-logo-4


© Copyright 2018 Spesia & Taylor Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved. Design by MoatzArt