Spesia & Taylor

Attorneys at Law

(815) 726-4311
  • History
  • Attorneys
    • James C. Byrne
    • John M. Spesia
    • Christian G. Spesia
    • Jeffrey S. Taylor
    • Michael R. Stiff
    • Jacob E. Gancarczyk
    • Michael A. Santschi
    • E. Kent Ayers
    • Thomas M. Ewert
    • Kent F. Slater
    • Haley G. Peters
    • Aly N. Harms
    • Alexander J. Boyd
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Eminent Domain
    • Employment & Civil Rights
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Real Estate & Zoning
    • Energy & Utilities
    • School Law
    • Municipal Law
    • Appellate Practice
  • News & Cases
  • Testimonials
  • Philanthropy
  • Contact
  • Home
You are here: Home / News & Cases / Spesia & Taylor Settles Personal Injury Lawsuit for $1,050,000.00

Spesia & Taylor Settles Personal Injury Lawsuit for $1,050,000.00

February 11, 2019

Gavel with money auto accident settlement - Spesia & Taylor

In January 2017 Attorneys Jeff Taylor and Tyler Moore filed a lawsuit in Cook County on behalf of a client who had sustained life-altering injuries to her arms and legs in a head-on collision. The client’s insurance company offered only $50,000 to settle, even though our client had undergone multiple surgeries and lost more than a year of wages during recovery.

During our investigation of the collision we discovered that the defendant-driver had been traveling to a work-related seminar at the time of the crash. The insurance company claimed that the defendant was not “working” at the time of the crash and argued that her employer’s million-dollar insurance policy was unavailable to redress our client’s injuries. Thus, the insurance company claimed that the only available source of recovery was the small $50,000 insurance policy from the defendant-driver. In order to recover from the employer’s commercial general liability policy, we developed our case strategy toward proving that the defendant-driver had been within the “scope of her employment” at the time of the crash.

Generally, the law in Illinois is that when people are traveling to or from work, they are not within the scope of their employment. However, this is not a bright-line rule and Illinois employs a multi-factor test to determine whether an individual is within the scope of his or her employment. Illinois has adopted the Second Restatement of Agency, which provides three general criteria to guide a court’s determination regarding the scope of employment:

“(1) Conduct of a servant is within the scope of employment if, but only if:
(a) it is of the kind he is employed to perform;
(b) it occurs substantially within the authorized time and space limits;
(c) it is actuated, at least in part, by a purpose to serve the master . . . ”

See Bagent v. Blessing Care Corp., 224 Ill. 2d 154, 164 (2007). In addition to this factor-based analysis, Illinois courts have held that an employee who is paid for their time spent in travel is an exception to the “going and coming rule.” See Commonwealth Edison Co. v. Industrial Com., 86 Ill. 2d 534 (1981). Understanding the case law, we were able to craft a litigation strategy and obtain critical witness testimony to support our argument that the defendant-driver was acting within the scope of her employment, thereby triggering coverage under the employer’s $1,000,000 insurance policy. We argued that the defendant driver was directed by her employer to attend a mandatory training event that was dozens of miles away from defendant’s normal place of employment and found pay-stubs to support our theory that the defendant was “on the clock.”

In addition to the scope of employment argument, we also obtained a copy of the defendant-employer’s insurance policy to evaluate whether there was insurance coverage under a “non-owned auto” provision. Under the “non-owned auto” provision, we argued that employer’s insurance policy afforded coverage for the defendant’s vehicle because it was “used in connection with” the employer’s business. See First Chicago Ins. Co. v. Molda, 2015 IL App (1st) 140548.

After nearly two years of litigation, multiple depositions of witnesses and doctors, the insurance company tendered the “policy limits” nearly four months prior to trial. The bottom line is that if you have been in a seriously injured, we recommend finding diligent attorneys who are not willing to settle for bottom dollar. If you have any questions about your automobile accident case, contact our skilled litigation attorneys at Spesia & Taylor.

Filed Under: News & Cases, Personal Injury & Malpractice

Schedule a Consultation:

Contact us today to set up a time to speak with a Spesia & Taylor professional about your legal needs. CLICK HERE!

Featured News:

Warm Heart Ministries Assists With The Opening Of The Harris High School In Likwakwanda, Malawi

When Fr. Philip Mbeta was enrolled at Illinois Benedictine University, studying for his PhD, he served as an associate pastor at St. Mary Immaculate ... Read More

Spesia & Taylor Successfully Defends the City of Crest Hill in High-Profile Civil Rights Case

By: Michael R. Stiff Spesia & Taylor attorneys Jeff Taylor, and Mike Stiff on July 28, 2021, won a Motion to Reconsider the 2019 denial of a ... Read More

Amendments to the Illinois residential real property transfer on death instrument act provides more estate plan tools to individuals in order to avoid probate

The Illinois Residential Real Property Transfer Act (755 ILCS 27/1, et seq.) (the “Act”) provides for an owner, or co-owners, to transfer Illinois ... Read More

Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” in 2021

This September, Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor were each recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” by LeadingLawyers.com. ... Read More

New Job Opportunity For Associate Attorney At The Law Firm Of Spesia & Taylor

Well established, dynamic, AV rated law firm is seeking associate attorney to join our practice. The law firm of Spesia & Taylor has been proudly ... Read More

1415 Black Road
Joliet, IL 60435
Phone: (815) 726-4311
Fax: (815) 846-2410

Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Sitemap

footer-logo-1footer-logo-3footer-logo-4


© Copyright 2018 Spesia & Taylor Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved. Design by MoatzArt