Spesia & Taylor

Attorneys at Law

(815) 726-4311
  • History
  • Attorneys
    • James C. Byrne
    • John M. Spesia
    • Christian G. Spesia
    • Jeffrey S. Taylor
    • Michael R. Stiff
    • Jacob E. Gancarczyk
    • Michael A. Santschi
    • E. Kent Ayers
    • Thomas M. Ewert
    • Kent F. Slater
    • Haley G. Peters
    • Aly N. Harms
    • Alexander J. Boyd
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Eminent Domain
    • Employment & Civil Rights
    • Commercial Litigation
    • Real Estate & Zoning
    • Energy & Utilities
    • School Law
    • Municipal Law
    • Appellate Practice
  • News & Cases
  • Testimonials
  • Philanthropy
  • Contact
  • Home
You are here: Home / News & Cases / School Boards: When May a School Board Refuse to Arbitrate a Grievance?

School Boards: When May a School Board Refuse to Arbitrate a Grievance?

January 15, 2016

As the Illinois Supreme Court held in Board of Education of the City of Chicago v. Illinois Educational Labor Relations Board, 215 IL 118043: “A school district may refuse to arbitrate a grievance where: (1) there is no contractual agreement to arbitrate the substance of the dispute or (2) the dispute is not arbitrable under section 10(b) of the Act because the subject matter of the dispute conflicts with Illinois law.” As the Court further held, “[T]he mere existence of a dispute” does not in and of itself make a matter arbitrable under a collective bargaining agreement (“CBA”).

In Board of Education v. IELRB, the issue was whether the placement of “Do Not Hire” designations in the personnel files of probationary appointed teachers, whom the board determined not to rehire, was an arbitrable violation of the CBA. Under both factors listed above, the Court held it was not.

First, the Court noted that the CBA followed the Illinois Educational Labor Relations Act (“IELRA”), with both stating that the employer is not bound to bargain over matters of inherent managerial policy, but is bound to bargain over wagers, hours and other terms and conditions of employment. Grievances filed over the Do Not Hire designations did not relate to wages, hours, or other terms and conditions of employment; rather, the grievances were related to the board’s ability to make hiring decisions. There was no contractual agreement, then, to make the grievances arbitrable. The Court further noted that arbitrating the grievances would violate Illinois statutes by requiring arbitration over those matters of “inherent managerial policy” under the IELRA. Moreover, arbitration of the grievances would violate the School Code by requiring the board to hire teachers whom it was precluded from hiring under the Code and delegate its discretionary power to terminate probationary teachers to an arbitrator.

Filed Under: News & Cases, School Law

Schedule a Consultation:

Contact us today to set up a time to speak with a Spesia & Taylor professional about your legal needs. CLICK HERE!

Featured News:

Spesia & Taylor Successfully Defends the City of Crest Hill in High-Profile Civil Rights Case

By: Michael R. Stiff Spesia & Taylor attorneys Jeff Taylor, and Mike Stiff on July 28, 2021, won a Motion to Reconsider the 2019 denial of a ... Read More

Amendments to the Illinois residential real property transfer on death instrument act provides more estate plan tools to individuals in order to avoid probate

The Illinois Residential Real Property Transfer Act (755 ILCS 27/1, et seq.) (the “Act”) provides for an owner, or co-owners, to transfer Illinois ... Read More

Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” in 2021

This September, Spesia & Taylor Partners John Spesia and Jeff Taylor were each recognized as “Top Personal Injury Lawyers” by LeadingLawyers.com. ... Read More

New Job Opportunity For Associate Attorney At The Law Firm Of Spesia & Taylor

Well established, dynamic, AV rated law firm is seeking associate attorney to join our practice. The law firm of Spesia & Taylor has been proudly ... Read More

Will County Legal Opportunity Scholarship Program Award Recipient Announced

Spesia & Taylor is a proud sponsor of the Will County Legal Opportunity Scholarship Program. The Scholarship awards a $5,000 per year up to three ... Read More

1415 Black Road
Joliet, IL 60435
Phone: (815) 726-4311
Fax: (815) 846-2410

Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Sitemap

footer-logo-1footer-logo-3footer-logo-4


© Copyright 2018 Spesia & Taylor Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved. Design by MoatzArt